A new report from think tank Rand explores lessons from the war in Ukraine that could apply to conflicts against China and Russia involving the USA.
A key finding of the report – entitled Dispersed, Disguised, and Degradable – is that the war of attrition in which Kyiv and Moscow are embroiled stems largely from neither combatant’s ability to gain air superiority.
In a war between NATO and Russia, NATO would be likely to secure air superiority given the big deficiencies observed in the Russian air force’s performance against Ukraine.
But Rand gives a caveat: “Even though NATO can expect to achieve superiority in the air in the traditional sense of keeping the enemy’s aircraft out of its airspace and being able to operate its own aircraft over enemy-held territory, air superiority will no longer be a guarantee of protection against observation and attack from the air.”
Russia will still be able to conduct deep strikes into NATO territory using ballistic missiles, cruise missiles, one-way attack drones, and reconnaissance uncrewed air systems (UAS).
Should China attempt to invade Taiwan – a situation analogous to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine – it might be more difficult for the USA to gain air superiority over Taiwan given China’s proximity to its neighbour, as well as the sheer mass of Chinese forces.
The report makes several other observations. One is that the distinction between cruise missiles and cheap one-way attack drones will blur.
For now, cruise missiles have the edge in speed, payload, and their resistance to jamming, but technological advances will continue to improve the performance of one-way attack drones. Both types of weapon will also benefit from greater autonomy, which will reduce their susceptibility to jamming.
Another point the report makes is that in a prolonged conflict, the ability to produce large numbers of UASs and one-way attack drones will be critical for success. Low-cost UASs allow strikes against distant targets and offer the potential to saturate air defence networks – a key Russian strategy in strikes against Ukrainian civilian infrastructure.
“UASs have been used as massed attack weapons in Ukraine designed to evade traditional air defences, but in future conflicts involving even more capable and better-resourced combatants, their importance as a tool for delivering mass to targets may increase further,” says the report.
“Large volumes of UASs have the potential to provide an additional solution to operational problems that were previously the domain of long-range precision fires, and to do so more sustainably in a protracted conflict.”
A new report from think tank Rand explores lessons from the war in Ukraine that could apply to conflicts against China and Russia involving the USA.
A key finding of the report – entitled Dispersed, Disguised, and Degradable – is that the war of attrition in which Kyiv and Moscow are embroiled stems largely from neither combatant’s ability to gain air superiority.
In a war between NATO and Russia, NATO would be likely to secure air superiority given the big deficiencies observed in the Russian air force’s performance against Ukraine.
But Rand gives a caveat: “Even though NATO can expect to achieve superiority in the air in the traditional sense of keeping the enemy’s aircraft out of its airspace and being able to operate its own aircraft over enemy-held territory, air superiority will no longer be a guarantee of protection against observation and attack from the air.”
Russia will still be able to conduct deep strikes into NATO territory using ballistic missiles, cruise missiles, one-way attack drones, and reconnaissance uncrewed air systems (UAS).
Should China attempt to invade Taiwan – a situation analogous to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine – it might be more difficult for the USA to gain air superiority over Taiwan given China’s proximity to its neighbour, as well as the sheer mass of Chinese forces.
The report makes several other observations. One is that the distinction between cruise missiles and cheap one-way attack drones will blur.
For now, cruise missiles have the edge in speed, payload, and their resistance to jamming, but technological advances will continue to improve the performance of one-way attack drones. Both types of weapon will also benefit from greater autonomy, which will reduce their susceptibility to jamming.
Another point the report makes is that in a prolonged conflict, the ability to produce large numbers of UASs and one-way attack drones will be critical for success. Low-cost UASs allow strikes against distant targets and offer the potential to saturate air defence networks – a key Russian strategy in strikes against Ukrainian civilian infrastructure.
“UASs have been used as massed attack weapons in Ukraine designed to evade traditional air defences, but in future conflicts involving even more capable and better-resourced combatants, their importance as a tool for delivering mass to targets may increase further,” says the report.
“Large volumes of UASs have the potential to provide an additional solution to operational problems that were previously the domain of long-range precision fires, and to do so more sustainably in a protracted conflict.”
Source link
Share This:
admin
Plan the perfect NYC Memorial Day weekend
Pack only what you need and avoid overpacking to streamline the check-in and security screening…
LA’s worst traffic areas and how to avoid them
Consider using alternative routes, such as Sepulveda Boulevard, which runs parallel to the 405 in…
Peruvian ministers discuss Gripen acquisition on official visit to Sweden | News
Senior government officials from Peru discussed the possibility of acquiring the latest Gripen E/F fighter…
Luxair on track for initial E195-E2 delivery before year-end
Luxair is confident of commencing initial Embraer 195-E2 operations in January next year, in line…
US government approves $1.85bn F-35 sustainment package for Poland and $861m C-17 support deal for UK RAF
The US government has cleared sustainment packages for Poland’s Lockheed Martin F-35A fighters and the…
UK’s One Air to take first 777F under operating lease
UK-based cargo carrier One Air is introducing its initial Boeing 777 freighter, one of a…
How is aviation tackling its contrails of concern? | Analysis
There is a cruel irony that one of the most visible parts of aviation’s impact…
Why military conversions are big business for executive jet producers | Analysis
With their long-endurance performance, plentiful onboard power and ability to carry a broad variety of…
Industry eyes greener future despite hydrogen adoption delay | Analysis
Any organisation funding the research and technology (R&T) activities necessary for aviation’s future faces a…
How will the UK wield its buying power as defence spending rises? | Analysis
The UK government’s commitment earlier this year to significantly boost defence spending over the coming…
Ground-vibration tests completed on fully-substituted MC-21
United Aircraft has completed ground-vibration testing of the import-substituted Yakovlev MC-21 prototype, moving the twinjet…
United Aircraft team details widebody twinjet family proposal similar to 787
Russian intellectual property authorities have registered a patent from aerospace firm United Aircraft detailing a…