French investigators believe the occurrence of dual-input situations, in which both pilots simultaneously operate the flight controls, is underestimated and should be monitored more closely.
This phenomenon had previously been associated with aircraft fitted with independent sidesticks, such as the current Airbus range, where the location of the sidestick and the absence of physical feedback means each pilot can experience difficulty perceiving the other’s actions.
But French investigation authority BEA says “several events” in recent have demonstrated that dual-input issue “also exists on aircraft with conventional flight controls”.
“The consequences can be significant,” it adds.
BEA highlights three incidents, each of which involved desynchronisation of the pilots’ control columns after the captain intervened “in the face of a danger deemed imminent”
These included an Air France Boeing 777-300ER go-around at Paris in April 2022, when the captain applied nose-down input to counter the first officer’s pitch-up command. Both pilots simultaneously acted on the controls for 53s including 12s of desynchronisation.
Just a day earlier a serious incident occurred to an Air Tahiti ATR 72 in French Polynesia, when the captain made control inputs to avert a hard touchdown during an unstable approach. BEA states that, unlike the 777, control desynchronisation on the ATR is irreversible.
BEA also refers to another ATR 72 event during descent to Sydney in February 2014. The Virgin Australia aircraft experienced a rapid increase in speed after encountering windshear, and the captain took the controls without declaring his intention – with the result that the first officer made opposite inputs, and exceeded the aircraft’s load limits.
Airbus analysis has previously identified that dual inputs can result from ‘involuntary’ and ‘comfort’ actions, which usually have limited effect, but also from ‘instinctive’ actions which are more significant.
The 777 and ATR events all arose from instinctive actions, says BEA, and desynchronisation risks following an imprecise – or perhaps unstable – trajectory.
Prevention of simultaneous piloting on certain aircraft types is based solely on the principle of announcing the assumption of control, it says.
“This principle remains fragile in dynamic and stressful situations,” it adds. “The aircraft concerned generally do not have a visual or audible alarm to alert that simultaneous actions on the flight controls are in progress.”
After the 777 incident Air France implemented monitoring for dual input on its 777s and 787s. BEA says it recorded a rate of 0.4 per 1,000 flights on 777s, a similar figure to the 0.44 on its Airbus fleet.
“The values are therefore comparable, while the reporting rate by pilots is not,” says BEA, adding that the Airbus dual-input cockpit alert “encourages reporting”.
BEA believes the frequency of such events is “underestimated” and that, to improve crew awareness, simultaneous piloting events should be monitored regardless of the flight-control configuration of the aircraft type.
French investigators believe the occurrence of dual-input situations, in which both pilots simultaneously operate the flight controls, is underestimated and should be monitored more closely.
This phenomenon had previously been associated with aircraft fitted with independent sidesticks, such as the current Airbus range, where the location of the sidestick and the absence of physical feedback means each pilot can experience difficulty perceiving the other’s actions.
But French investigation authority BEA says “several events” in recent have demonstrated that dual-input issue “also exists on aircraft with conventional flight controls”.
“The consequences can be significant,” it adds.
BEA highlights three incidents, each of which involved desynchronisation of the pilots’ control columns after the captain intervened “in the face of a danger deemed imminent”
These included an Air France Boeing 777-300ER go-around at Paris in April 2022, when the captain applied nose-down input to counter the first officer’s pitch-up command. Both pilots simultaneously acted on the controls for 53s including 12s of desynchronisation.
Just a day earlier a serious incident occurred to an Air Tahiti ATR 72 in French Polynesia, when the captain made control inputs to avert a hard touchdown during an unstable approach. BEA states that, unlike the 777, control desynchronisation on the ATR is irreversible.
BEA also refers to another ATR 72 event during descent to Sydney in February 2014. The Virgin Australia aircraft experienced a rapid increase in speed after encountering windshear, and the captain took the controls without declaring his intention – with the result that the first officer made opposite inputs, and exceeded the aircraft’s load limits.
Airbus analysis has previously identified that dual inputs can result from ‘involuntary’ and ‘comfort’ actions, which usually have limited effect, but also from ‘instinctive’ actions which are more significant.
The 777 and ATR events all arose from instinctive actions, says BEA, and desynchronisation risks following an imprecise – or perhaps unstable – trajectory.
Prevention of simultaneous piloting on certain aircraft types is based solely on the principle of announcing the assumption of control, it says.
“This principle remains fragile in dynamic and stressful situations,” it adds. “The aircraft concerned generally do not have a visual or audible alarm to alert that simultaneous actions on the flight controls are in progress.”
After the 777 incident Air France implemented monitoring for dual input on its 777s and 787s. BEA says it recorded a rate of 0.4 per 1,000 flights on 777s, a similar figure to the 0.44 on its Airbus fleet.
“The values are therefore comparable, while the reporting rate by pilots is not,” says BEA, adding that the Airbus dual-input cockpit alert “encourages reporting”.
BEA believes the frequency of such events is “underestimated” and that, to improve crew awareness, simultaneous piloting events should be monitored regardless of the flight-control configuration of the aircraft type.
Source link
Share This:
admin
Plan the perfect NYC Memorial Day weekend
Pack only what you need and avoid overpacking to streamline the check-in and security screening…
LA’s worst traffic areas and how to avoid them
Consider using alternative routes, such as Sepulveda Boulevard, which runs parallel to the 405 in…
ITA Airways, United secure approval for codeshare partnership | News
ITA Airways is working to establish a codeshare relationship with United Airlines, following last month’s…
Martinair A350F trimmed from Air France-KLM backlog
One of KLM cargo division Martinair’s Airbus A350 freighters has been dropped from the carrier’s…
Safran aims to recover Leap delivery backlog to Airbus by end-October
Safran is aiming to recover the backlog of CFM International Leap-1A engine deliveries to Airbus…
Indonesian Aerospace expands cooperation with Turkish defence industry after ordering 48 TAI Kaan fighters
Indonesian Aerospace has deepened ties with Turkey’s defence aerospace industry amid Jakarta’s plans to obtain…
Angara maintenance certificate revoked following inspection after An-24 crash
Russian federal air transport regulator Rosaviatsia has revoked the maintenance certificate of Siberia’s Angara Airlines,…
Rolls-Royce ‘on track’ with second phase of durability package for 787 and A330neo
Rolls-Royce says it remains “on track” to deliver a 30% time-on-wing improvement for the Trent…
BAE chief hails Turkish Typhoon pact, but sidesteps jet trainer JV reports | News
BAE Systems chief executive Charles Woodburn has welcomed Turkey’s memorandum of understanding (MoU) linked to…
Bombardier still pondering option of Belfast acquisition | News
Bombardier is still not ruling out acquiring part of its former Belfast site to safeguard…
Rival submissions to expand Heathrow each promise third runway in a decade
Two proposals for expansion at London Heathrow each foresee a third runway – albeit of…
Otto Aviation picks Italian specialist to design Phantom’s fuel system
US firm Otto Aviation, which is developing a low-emission business jet, has selected Italian-based Secondo…